You are not logined. Using English.
SITO: discussion: discuss!  
a calmer tomorrow help: Viewing a discussion message
by Jon Van Oast [uwi SITOme] [email Jon Van Oast] 2004-01-24 10:04:06 [8174]
first, i have taken this outta the gridcosm discussion, but just wanted to address a few things. primarily, i wanted to "think out loud" about my take on art being sold on sito, using gre as an example. i would like to note, though, that i mean this to apply in a more general case.

sunny, thanks for responding. i respect your creeped-out-ness, but fear even more making someone feel unwanted or jeered because of what they believe in. there are, i suppose, exceptions to this, as i suspect if we tried hard enough (ewww) we could all dream up some awful experience where what a person believed in was collectively objectionable. but lets not go there right now.... anyway, this is what fueled my panic and jumping in wanting to chill things out a bit.

(that said, i am a little confused and concerned over whats up with gre's link to a "homepage". it is a strange domain choice, to say the least! i thank you, sny, for addressing this in her personal discussion area -- we will see whats up, i hope.)

the issue of non-commercialism and sito is a big one to me (and i think ed would say the same about him). we (and i mean "the collective sito", as this is a topic open for discussion) have struggled with this issue, wondering even if adding something as simple as the 4 characters "$100" to the end of an artchive description is acceptable.

it all comes down to a judgement call. i think most sitoans are not against an artist making money (let alone a living) from their work, or even somehow admitting this on sito. but where does this cross the line into exploiting the generally non-commercialness of sito? its a very good (and difficult) question.

i, for one, do not want to have to deal with a formalized, quantified rule set as to what is too much or acceptable. i can see that being, however, a possibility. personally, i just make the judgement myself, but am always open to other thoughts on the matter. (for the record, ed is outta town til tomorrow; but i do NOT want to consider his and my voices the only ones, by any means.)

let me outline my judgement call in ginas case, as an example. my opinions of course. firstly, her bio (albeit a bit over-the-top [imho!] with the html) is sincere and personal. it talks about her motive to create. these are nice thing, but its worth noting that in its ~600 words(!) there is not any mention of selling art. i count this in the "plus" column. as i said, i have no idea what is up with her choice of url, tho.

now, turning to her artchive descriptions. they are (again, my opinion) a little heavy on the info about selling, but about half of that is technical info about what you would get (e.g.

"original prints - these are prints that are created directly from the original image, not copies of a printed image."
). basically, when i look at the text of the descriptions, i see an actual blurb about the image (a "plus", as opposed to just jumping in to a sales pitch), followed by something saying
"prints are available for $xxx, signed by the artist"
. (as i said in my original post, my personal verdict is out as to the "vote for me" link, let alone its occasional lack of the </a> tag closing it! but that last part is a technical issue.)

in the end: a judgement call. very tough to codify, i think. even if a rule of no prices is created, the text becomes

"images are available as original prints on canvas, signed & dated by yours truly. if interested, please contact me."
i personally dont see a problem with this, but want this to be an open discussion.

thanks (everyone) for bearing with this. thanks also (always!) to all the artists on sito, and i say that both personally and as some kinda switch-thrower on generally, i am going to lean to the side of inclusiveness, because i want sito to feel as welcoming as possible. this is NOT an easy thing (take language barriers as one example out of many). personal gallery spaces (the artchives) is tricky enough, let alone throw into the mix the shared (and often volatile!) playspace of gridcosm. wow, its not easy at all.

but i am thankful for all of you being here. i am thrilled to have you stick around. heck, i even welcome the occasional lively debate to help remind us life isnt always mindlessly simple. lets keep talking and playing and mostly getting along.

In reply to:
Re: holy crap calm down!
on the departure of GRE

Active/New discussions on SITO have been moved to Google Groups.

Please check out the SITO general and Gridcosm topics over there.

OLDER THREADS - for archival reference only
[compact]=[next 90]help: Discussion message list
 anadenunk  12-01-10 23:01
drop-out artists?
 Wild(e) StYLe Artz  11-02-02 02:30
Re: who was on the first pez?
 guest  09-03-21 21:06
Art that Talks by Ray Tapajna  08-12-03 03:01
Re: Animal Testing on Acid
 guest  08-11-01 19:17
 guest:No,Ieie(avisolegal+#)  08-10-14 07:16
Re: Is he just bi-curious? Is he secretly gay? What is he up to?
 guest (psychologogy major)  08-09-09 21:58
Re: ... and the turd award goes to... (envelope please)
 Nata Lukas  08-03-19 14:59
Re: ... and the turd award goes to... (envelope please)
 guest  08-03-19 14:06
Re: What I really want to see in Gridcosm
 jer  07-12-28 00:52
Re: The Real John Holmes - Wonderland Murders Exposed!
 guest  07-10-31 11:32
fucking cunt
 from da bitch dat hates u  07-10-14 03:26
Re: your a bitch!!!!
 guest  07-10-14 03:23
you f***ing w***er
 guest  06-11-13 04:42
Re: Sein Und Zeit
 Sein und Zeit  06-11-12 03:16
Re: Sein Und Zeit
 Sein und Zeit  06-11-12 03:09
Re: Sein Und Zeit
 Sein und Zeit  06-11-12 03:08
Re: Sein Und Zeit
 Sein und Zeit  06-11-12 03:08
Re: isketch - multiuser drawing game
 guest  06-10-09 01:18
Re: Sein Und Zeit
 Jon Van Oast  06-08-31 04:44
Sein Und Zeit
 MARK SUNSHINE  06-08-31 01:15
Re: Is he just bi-curious? Is he secretly gay? What is he up to?
 guest  06-08-22 19:38
need info regarding SITO training for Door Supervisor
 waxy  06-05-06 01:31
Re: [no subject]
 waxy  06-05-06 01:29
2170 15 \\'2173// 1// 1337
 ─quivalenzfaktor  06-04-30 08:00
Nude Posing
 Alan So cal  06-04-28 15:15
Surface Magazine 9th Annual Avant Guardian Project
 guest  06-04-24 17:58
[no subject]
 guest  06-02-07 16:37
thrivers wanted.  06-01-29 05:40
Animal Testing on Acid
 Animal Tester HATER  06-01-19 21:58
NC Artist
 guest  05-12-06 01:19
 guest  05-11-27 06:54
 guest  05-11-22 07:04
Re: about riots
 Ed Stastny  05-11-09 14:18
Re: about riots
 Jon Van Oast  05-11-08 06:19 about riots
 Just In Time JIT  05-11-08 04:11
Re: anyone looking for music
 guest  05-10-29 02:17
Is he just bi-curious? Is he secretly gay? What is he up to?
 guest  05-10-21 16:23
Re: more broken glass than any girls ever seen
 guest  05-09-07 21:57
Hey! Theres no virgins waiting for you in paradise!
 Altarego  05-07-07 23:03
Artificial meat
 Altarego  05-07-07 22:52
EXTENDED DEADLINE: Surface Magazine's 8th Annual Avant Guardian Project
 guest  05-05-09 21:41
Friom SNY
 MARK SUNSHINE  04-12-31 15:05
Re: sito exodus 2005
 Cas Rusnov  04-12-08 17:50
sito exodus 2005
 Jon Van Oast  04-12-08 06:42
Re: Thanks everybody, partition is gone.
 Jon Van Oast  04-12-08 03:48
this thread
 Jon Van Oast  04-12-03 22:43
Re: your a bitch!!!!
 guest  04-12-03 21:31
your a bitch!!!!
 guest  04-12-03 21:29
The Real John Holmes - Wonderland Murders Exposed!  04-10-23 02:45
who is the corporation that sponsors sito?
 dale mc farlane aka 'DAWK''  04-07-24 06:24
Re: SITOLand = Slovenia
 Jon Van Oast  04-06-23 20:50
SITOLand = Slovenia
 Mike Huber  04-06-23 18:42
[SUNSHINE] News Weird
 Armoredbaby  04-06-15 01:08
Spring cleaning
 Altarego  04-05-06 05:52
What if Barrabas was crucified instead of Jesus?
 Altarego  04-04-07 04:57
Re: How about those new stats?
 Patrick Deshaye  04-02-21 15:14
Re: How about those new stats?
 Jon Van Oast  04-02-21 05:46
the link
 Jon Van Oast  04-01-24 15:35
a calmer tomorrow
 Jon Van Oast  04-01-24 10:04
 Jon Van Oast  04-01-17 20:59
 Racist  04-01-17 18:45
Re: unilateral moratorium
 Elena H. Fischer in Prangins, CH  03-12-21 09:42
Re: [no subject]
 Elena H. Fischer in Prangins, CH  03-12-21 09:39
friends  03-12-08 10:17
Re: INtersting e-mail I got -- collab ( french and english text)
 Jon Van Oast  03-11-21 01:16
INtersting e-mail I got -- collab ( french and english text)
 MARK SUNSHINE  03-11-20 22:30
specific laws....bernie 8398 message
 guestbernadettesmith1212com....11-19-03---n35018886....-564191310news......  03-11-19 23:30
 mno  03-09-18 09:25
Re: You People
 Cas Rusnov  03-08-28 16:05
Re: You People
 Mike Casey  03-08-28 07:48
Re: You People
 Mike Casey  03-08-28 07:36
You People
 Mike Casey  03-08-28 07:30
Re: Surreal unique Paintings
 guest  03-08-24 08:05
Re: Surreal unique Paintings
 guest  03-08-24 06:12
 guest  03-08-15 18:57
New product for 2d & 3d artists
 guest  03-06-10 12:43
hansik gebert archive/new downloads
 guest  03-05-06 13:59
hansik gebert archive  03-04-22 16:16
Fun stuff!
 Nata Lukas  03-03-01 08:41
invisible cloak
 goof  03-02-08 15:25
[COLLAB] Anyone seen this?
 Tontino ( SNY )  03-01-17 02:44
What do you think about this paintings??
 suzlee  03-01-03 03:13
Interesting Flash game about the Americas
 MARK SUNSHINE  02-11-19 05:45
portrait of the artist as a homepage
 tgd  02-11-11 17:29
 jd  02-11-08 01:31
another corpse
 tgd  02-11-04 22:26
roger art
 tgd  02-10-27 13:28
match book art
 tgd  02-10-25 18:18
patent art
 googoo head  02-10-25 14:07
Contact SITO  |  About SITO  |  Make a Donation  |  Site Map  |  RSS Feed  |  Hosting provided by TOONLET :(   Apparent Systems, Inc.